# Option A2 — steel roof without new insulation

Recalculated September 19, 2026. Six cabins in Hagar Township, Michigan. A (insulated steel) and B (shingle overlay) remain available. All dollar amounts are USD, excluding tax and permit allowances by owner direction. Costs are purchasing allowances, not a delivered quote or approved construction design.

## Assembly and geometry

A2, outside to inside: formed steel panels → flat 2×4 purlins → retained asphalt shingles / underlayment → existing wood deck and four structural frames. No new foam, foam plates or tape. No added downslope battens or soffit cladding. Exposed wood, cabin geometry, openings, deck and colors are unchanged. Winter shutdown/unheated and summer air conditioning remain the operating assumptions. A2 adds no insulation R-value. Purlin gaps are not represented as a designed continuous ventilation system.

The existing roof is 20 ft along each slope × 24 ft front-to-back; 20 ft between lower outside roof edges. Each face = 480 SF; cabin = 960 SF; six cabins = **5,760 SF**. Half-span 10 ft, rise √(20²−10²) = 17.3205 ft, slope 60°. Four structural frames at z = −10, −3⅓, +3⅓, +10 ft; three 6′8″ bays and 2 ft overhang at each end.

| Measure | A: insulated steel | A2: no insulation |
|---|---:|---:|
| New foam | 2 in | 0 |
| Flat purlin thickness | 1.5 in | 1.5 in |
| New build-up excluding panel profile | 3.5 in | 1.5 in |
| Model pan thickness | .24 in | .24 in |
| Modeled rib envelope above build-up | .954 in | .954 in |
| Pan extension to plumb ridge, along slope | 7.00 in | 3.53 in |
| Panel pricing length, rounded up over rib envelope | 20′9″ | 20′5″ |
| Ordered panel LF, 102 pieces | 2,116.5 | 2,082.5 |
| Ordered coverage at 36 in | 6,349.5 SF | 6,247.5 SF |
| Rake length, pan envelope before laps | 493.99 LF | 487.07 LF |
| Eaves before laps | 288 LF | 288 LF |
| Ridge before laps | 144 LF | 144 LF |

Ridge derivation: a parallel roof plane raised normal to the 60° slope needs an uphill extension of **√3 × normal offset** to meet the plumb ridge. The scene measures offsets from the old deck top and includes .30 in of retained shingles. Pan extension = √3 × (.30 + new build-up + .24). Highest rib envelope = √3 × (.30 + new build-up + .954). Pricing length = 240 in + the rib extension, rounded up to the next inch. These are conservative model-based pricing lengths, **not fabrication cut lengths**. A selected profile, ridge setback/cap coverage, field measurements and eave projection may change them. Removing 2 in normal thickness lowers the theoretical ridge intersection by 4 in vertically and reduces the along-slope intersection by 3.464 in; the cabin itself does not change.

**Correction to earlier estimate:** 20′3″ / 2,065.5 LF did not cover the insulated model's raised ridge intersection. A now prices 51 additional LF × $4 = $204 materials, or $234.60 after contingency. A2 is measured independently, not simply charged the same steel quantity as A.

## Six-cabin quantities

- **Field panels:** 8 per face × 2 faces × 6 cabins = 96 installed. Add 6 spare panels = **102** at 36-in effective coverage. A2 prices 20′5″ each = 2,082.5 LF, 6,247.5 SF effective purchasing coverage, 8.46% above the fixed net area; this includes length and spare allowances.
- **Purlins:** 11 rows per face × 12 faces = **132 rows**, each 24 ft, **3,168 installed LF**. Model row centers are 23.6496 in apart, just under the nominal 24-in layout, inset 1.752 in from each end of the 20-ft field.
- **Staggered segments:** one 8′8″ and one 15′4″ piece per row. Alternate the joint between the two intermediate frames. Total **264 installed pieces**. Purchase **132 ten-foot + 132 sixteen-foot boards**, 3,432 LF. This leaves 264 LF / 8.33% cutting offcuts before kerf. The $2,298.24 inherited lumber allowance corresponds to $17.411 per 10-ft/16-ft pair, not verified individual board prices. No additional breakage stock is in that quantity; contingency remains.
- **Insulation:** A2 = **0 sheets, 0 SF, 0 tape, 0 foam holding plates**. A retains 192 4×8 sheets / 6,144 SF, $6,720, plus $600 tape.
- **Trim:** A2 pan-envelope rake 487.07 LF + eave 288 LF + ridge 144 LF = **919.07 net LF**. An illustrative ten-foot-stock order uses 3 lengths for each of 24 rakes, 12 eaves and 6 ridges: **126 ten-foot pieces / 1,260 purchased LF**, before optimizing offcut reuse. Three 10-ft lengths cover each run with ordinary lap allowances; confirm actual laps and manufacturer profiles. The animation uses simplified segmented trim rather than a fabrication cut list. A has 925.99 net LF and the same provisional stock-piece count. Keep the **$5,100 trim allowance in each** until repeated shallower profiles are quoted; do not assume price is proportional to face depth.
- **Closures/sealants:** retain the $840 allowance. With 3-ft closure strips at 288 LF of eaves plus 288 LF at both ridge sides, allow **192 installed strips / 216 purchased** including 12.5% spare. Actual inside/outside closures, venting and sealant types depend on the selected system. Included within the lump allowance, not an extra cost.
- **Backing/repairs:** retain $1,920, pending condition review; no scope or quantity saving is assumed solely because the roof is thinner.

## Fasteners — model versus purchasing

The visualization retains **176 structural anchor locations per cabin / 1,056 total**: 11 rows × 2 faces × 4 frame crossings × 2 solid-lumber plies. It also retains **352 panel-screw locations per cabin / 2,112 total**: 8 panels × 11 rows × 2 illustrative fasteners × 2 faces. A2's odometer therefore ends at **528 modeled fasteners per cabin**, including no foam plates. This is an illustrative location count, not the final fastening schedule. Stitch/trim procurement reserves are not all individually modeled.

For A2 purchase **1,200 structural anchors**, **4,000 gasketed panel screws**, and **1,000 stitch/trim screws**. The panel reserve deliberately exceeds the simplified animation to allow a denser selected-profile/edge pattern; it is not an engineered minimum. Splice end distances, support/blocking, fastener diameter and uplift requirements remain unresolved. Anchors in A2 are shown 2 in shorter than A, preserving modeled embedment. Their modeled 4.24-in overall shaft length is illustrative; select a standard length only after confirming retained layers and required sound-wood embedment. Panel screw length does not shorten with removal of foam because the screw still engages the same 1.5-in purlin.

Price assumptions, explicitly **not researched supplier unit prices**:

| A2 fastener type | Purchase count | Allowance each | Extended |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Structural anchors | 1,200 | $1.00 | $1,200 |
| Gasketed panel screws | 4,000 | $0.20 | $800 |
| Stitch / trim screws | 1,000 | $0.18 | $180 |
| **Total** | **6,200** | | **$2,180** |

A retains its earlier $3,480 combined fastener allowance; it was not broken into a supported supplier quote. The $1,300 difference is a **re-estimated package difference**, not a claimed exact price for deleted foam plates. Confirm both packages on the same vendor quote.

## Complete estimate at the $4/LF purchasing target

| Line | A | A2 | B: shingles |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Field roof covering | $8,466.00 | $8,330.00 | $7,750.00 |
| Foam sheets | $6,720.00 | $0 | $0 |
| Foam tape | $600.00 | $0 | $0 |
| Purlins | $2,298.24 | $2,298.24 | $0 |
| Fasteners | $3,480.00 | $2,180.00 | $600.00 |
| Starter | $0 | $0 | $439.76 |
| Edge trim / flashing / ridge | $5,100.00 | $5,100.00 | $2,160.79 |
| Closures / sealants / hand-sealing | $840.00 | $840.00 | $450.00 |
| Backing / repairs | $1,920.00 | $1,920.00 | $1,920.00 |
| **Materials** | **$29,424.24** | **$20,668.24** | **$13,320.55** |
| Helper, 40 days × $200 | $8,000.00 | $8,000.00 | $8,000.00 |
| Equipment / access | $1,800.00 | $1,800.00 | $1,800.00 |
| Delivery / handling | $1,200.00 | $1,200.00 | $1,200.00 |
| 15% contingency on all direct costs | $6,063.64 | $4,750.24 | $3,648.08 |
| **Six cabins** | **$46,487.88** | **$36,418.48** | **$27,968.63** |
| **Per cabin** | **$7,747.98** | **$6,069.75** | **$4,661.44** |

A2 saves **$10,069.40 versus corrected A**: $6,720 foam + $600 tape + $1,300 fastener package difference + $136 shorter panels = $8,756 direct materials, plus $1,313.40 less contingency. Versus the former uncorrected A total of $46,253.28, A2 is $9,834.80 lower. A2 is $8,449.84 above B. Calculations use unrounded totals; displayed cents can differ by one cent when subtracted.

Helper time, access equipment, delivery, closures and repairs are held constant. Skipping foam should remove work, but there is no supported day-by-day production estimate to credit a labor saving. Painting, door/light replacements, deck improvements and major structural repairs remain excluded. No tax, permit allowance or assumed new condensation membrane is included. Any manufacturer-required change is a scope change to price before ordering.

## Sources and unresolved product details

[DuraMetal's published pricing](https://munciemetalroofing.com/pricing/) was rechecked September 19, 2026: 26-ga G-Rib standard-color benchmark $3.78/LF, selected premium colors $4.05/LF; page marked updated May 2026. The $4/LF target is not a confirmed manufacturer-direct delivered quote, nor confirmation that every palette color qualifies.

[Fabral's published reroofing guidance, Technical Bulletin 721](https://beta.fabral.com/fabral-technical-bulletin-721-re-roofing-with-metal/) and [storage / installation guidance](https://beta.fabral.com/resource/storage-and-installation-instructions/) describe reroofing and attachment into suitable support. Manufacturer/profile selection still controls underlayment, condensation treatment, panel span, connections and closures. These generic references do not approve this cabin assembly. Retained underlayment and unheated winter use do not by themselves settle summer condensation behavior.

Finish imagery for A2 reuses the steel palette reference and is labeled accordingly. A2's assembled/exploded model and construction animation carry its actual reduced build-up, shorter anchors, reduced trim faces and omitted insulation inventory. All cabin geometry and Forest & Oxblood defaults are preserved.
